WeeklyWorker

19.11.2026
Alan Milburn: well-paid big business adviser

Milburn’s recipe for social murder

Andy Burnham says no one need lose out when it comes to solving the ‘Neets crisis’. But the reality will be conscription into low-paid, dead-end jobs for the benefit of the least competitive sections of the capitalist class. Ian Spencer investigates

November 17 saw the publication of an ‘independent report’ from the Department for Work and Pensions entitled ‘From a welfare state to a working state: a new settlement for the next generation’. It looks set to recreate one of the more vicious aspects of Margaret Thatcher’s regime - the removal of benefits from young people - and is likely to have similar consequences.

The current Labour government, like Tory and coalition governments before it, is greatly concerned by the number of young people who are ‘not in education, employment or training’ (Neet). Alan Milburn, the former Labour health secretary, describes the report as “one of the most important things I have done in my public life”.1 It asserts that nearly one million young people - around one in eight - are out of education and employment. Most, it goes on to say, are economically inactive rather than looking for work and six in 10 have never had a job: “Today’s Neet crisis is no longer the old story of a temporary cycle of youth unemployment. It is a new phenomenon of youth detachment.”

It goes on to say, just two paragraphs later, that the Neet rate has barely been below 10% in the last 25 years. So not new then. In fact, for far longer, the youth unemployment rate has been obstinately three times higher than the general unemployment rate. Young people have borne the brunt of the consequences of de-industrialisation, the disappearance of paid apprenticeships and austerity.

Moreover, this is despite the fact that further and higher education have been used to soak up youth unemployment for decades. In 1979, 12% to 14% of young people entered higher education, with 7.5% of 18-year-olds in universities.2 By 2018 this had risen to 50%, most incurring debts of around £50k for the privilege.

But this is not addressed in Milburn’s report. Instead, it focuses on the economic consequences. Slower growth, lower productivity and lost skills, at a time when there are likely to be significant changes in the labour market, while “the country will pay an ever higher fiscal price through an increasingly unaffordable benefits bill, as more young people become trapped in economic inactivity”. After all, these young people will be needed to earn and pay taxes to support the growing number of those living to old age.

Apparently, among the causes of the problem is a health service “organised around diagnosing and treating illness once it has taken hold rather than identifying risk, preventing problems from escalating and keeping young people participating in education and employment”. This was identified in the interim report in May 2026, and focused on the alleged rise in mental health problems.3

The education system is also cited as “not providing young people with the aptitudes, as well as the qualifications, they need to succeed in a fast-changing labour market”. The report goes on to exhort employers, educators and health professionals to play their part in solving the crisis, which it locates in the structure of an abstract economy, rather than the decline of capital.

New Labour

One would have thought that a former member of the International Marxist Group, as Milburn was, might have known better, but it would seem not.4 In fact, it is almost as if his career had prepared him for this very moment. Having joined the Labour Party, he became the MP for Darlington and quickly supported Blair’s New Labour project. He was suitably rewarded, in 1997, with a job as a minister in the department of health, during which time he had responsibility for driving through private finance deals on hospitals.

He pleased his masters so much that Milburn was rewarded with a cabinet post as chief secretary to the treasury (from 1998 to 1999) and later as secretary of state for health. It was about this time he introduced NHS foundation trusts. Following his resignation in 2003, he secured a £30,000-a-year part-time job advising Bridgepoint Capital - a venture firm heavily involved in financing private healthcare firms moving into the NHS.5

Milburn did not seek re-election in the 2010 general election. By the time he stood down as an MP, Milburn had an income of at least £115,000 a year from five companies.6 He was later singled out as chair of the Social Mobility Commission by the Tory/Lib Dem coalition government. He continues to be a senior adviser to PricewaterhouseCoopers as chair of their UK health industry oversight board.

So, in his current role, appointed under Keir Starmer, to look at the Neets question, we see the familiar story of a professional politician, who is able to use his position for considerable financial gain and then cites the health service, of which he was previously briefly in charge, as being one of the reasons for the high level of youth non-participation in the labour market.

In September 1988, the Thatcher government ended automatic entitlement to general welfare benefits, specifically income support for almost all unemployed 16- and 17-year-olds. This led to a drastic increase in poverty, as it forced young people to rely on their family for support, and homelessness, where that support was not forthcoming.7 Ironically, this led to an increase in the number of Neets and a reliance on the Youth Training Scheme, which was transparently exploitative. Since then, the emphasis has shifted to an expanded higher-education sector, where students rely on mortgage-size loans to ‘bridge the gap’ between school and work and which can be passed off as social mobility.

But, as we know, the connection between Thatcher and Blair’s New Labour project is seamless and Milburn seems determined to repeat the process, where young claimants who refuse the offer of work face the prospect of being stripped of benefits. Economic conscription is to be applied to low-paid sectors of the economy, where there are significant staffing shortages, such as social care and the hospitality industry.

Killing them

It is not difficult to show that benefit cuts have a direct impact on mortality and morbidity among the poor. The period since the end of World War II has generally seen a steady improvement in a range of social indicators of health and welfare. However, more recently the improvement has been slowing, and this is a trend across several relatively wealthy economies. The UK has the distinction of seeing a decline in average life expectancy and this has a demonstrable relationship to the austerity policies of the Tory/Lib Dem coalition government, which Alan Milburn was happy to advise.8

We also know from decades of empirical evidence that social class (even if conceived of in Weberian sociological terms) is the most fundamental determinant of inequalities in health that result in far higher death rates among the poorest in society. While governments have, one way or another, acknowledged this, typically it is rationalised as being the consequence of lifestyle choices or, as with the Milburn report, speciously attributed to educational and health policy decisions.

Friedrich Engels understood rather better and expressed it well in 1845 in The condition of the working class in England:

When one individual inflicts bodily injury upon another such injury that death results, we call the deed manslaughter; when the assailant knew in advance that the injury would be fatal, we call his deed murder. But when society places hundreds of proletarians in such a position that they inevitably meet a too early and an unnatural death, one which is quite as much a death by violence as that by the sword or bullet; when it deprives thousands of the necessaries of life, places them under conditions in which they cannot live - forces them, through the strong arm of the law, to remain in such conditions until that death ensues, which is the inevitable consequence - knows that these thousands of victims must perish, and yet permits these conditions to remain, its deed is murder just as surely as the deed of the single individual; disguised, malicious murder, murder against which none can defend himself, which does not seem what it is, because no man sees the murderer, because the death of the victim seems a natural one, since the offence is more one of omission than of commission. But murder it remains.9

As communists we say all those who can work should be able to find work and thus contribute to society. Lenin, famously, was not afraid to draw on a biblical aphorism: “he who does not work, neither shall he eat” (2 Thessalonians 3:10). But he did so in the context of creating a society of freely associating producers, particularly in the early stages of communism, where the working class has become the ruling class. Moreover, Marx talked about the higher phase of communism, where free, creative labour would become “man’s prime want”.

What successive bourgeois governments have in mind though is forcing young people to take any job at any rate of pay in the interests of capital. The reserve army of labour can only exert its downward pressure on workers’ pay if it can be integrated into the workforce. This will become even more forceful in times of preparation for war.

Hardly a day goes by without political pundits giving vent to the idea that the expenditure on benefits is the principal reason for a low-growth economy. There is no question that major structural changes to the workplace are coming, whether due to AI or the intensification of class struggle, or in fact both. The attacks on the young (and the rest of the working class, for that matter) have led to major strikes and uprisings across Europe and beyond.

Shorter hours

The demand for a shorter working week has been fundamental to the workers’ movement for generations, but has been lost from view for some time. Communists are for the abolition of wage slavery in favour of free, creative labour to meet human needs.

We are in favour of the expansion of free education for all to allow the fullest development of human potential. But education and training, as far as Milburn’s interim report is concerned, is merely to serve as a “bridge from school to work”. The sons and daughters of the ruling class will, of course, continue to go to the same universities and study the subjects most conducive to those in charge.

In the meantime, the sons and daughters of workers are shepherded towards a life of debt bondage for a degree, which has become the entry-level qualification for relatively menial work - jobs which could just as easily be obtained with a few ‘O levels’ a generation earlier.

The crisis in mental health, which is seen as a barrier to increasing the reserve army of labour, is, in part, an expression of the human alienation under contemporary social relations. The Milburn report will not change that - or the forcing of young people to do soul-destroying jobs for poverty wages.


  1. . www.gov.uk/government/publications/from-a-welfare-state-to-a-working-state-a-new-settlement-for-the-next-generation.↩︎

  2. . www.theguardian.com/education/2016/jun/24/has-university-life-changed-student-experience-past-present-parents-vox-pops.↩︎

  3. . www.gov.uk/government/publications/young-people-and-work-interim-report/young-people-and-work-interim-report.↩︎

  4. . www.theguardian.com/society/2001/may/07/nhsstaff.health.↩︎

  5. . news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/3633738.stm.↩︎

  6. . www.thenorthernecho.co.uk/news/newsediting/4463334.MP____not_quitting_over_jobs_scrutiny.↩︎

  7. . dera.ioe.ac.uk/id/eprint/15119/2/bridging-the-gap.pdf.↩︎

  8. . D Walsh and G McCartney Social murder Bristol 2025.↩︎

  9. . www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/download/pdf/condition-working-class-england.pdf.↩︎